I don't believe he fooled around on me
Tells me that he loves me
Shows me that he needs me, needs me
And he's with me all the time
You say you saw him down at Crystal Lake Yes, we did
Are you sure that it was him It was him
He told me he'd be working late
And he never learned to swim
They were laughing Huh
They were splashing What
They were working on their tans
They were talking No way
It was shocking
They were even holding hands Oh yeah
I should have seen this from a mile away
I could read it in his eyes
I didn't think that it would end this way
But I shouldn't be surprised
Just last weekend
Saw him speaking
To a girl with big brown eyes
They were flirting
And now I'm certain
I'm getting wrapped up in his lies, oh yeah
I should have seen this from a mile away
I could read it in his eyes
Didn't think that it would end this way
But I shouldn't be surprised
I shouldn't be surprised
No, I shouldn't be surprised